Topic: Preparing for Battle

Desmond Granger

Date: 2013-08-11 08:47 EST
As happy and settled as Desmond had become these last few months since the attempt on his life, it was time to go back to work. One last case before moving to Rhy'Din permanently, and it was a big one. The Nicoletti Trial. Des had only met with Elena De Luca once before, back in New York before she'd been put into witness protection, before she had disappeared from public view. She was the key witness and without her testimony, there might not be a trial, hence it was of paramount importance to keep her safe, no matter the cost. This was the most important case of Desmond's career, not only on a professional level but a personal one. It wasn't just about the attempt on his life, but all the innocent blood that had been spilled. Des had personally vowed to put Samuel Nicoletti away for life, but more importantly, he wanted his Old Man.

Elena just wanted everything over and done with. It had been ten months since she was first arrested and made her deal, since the D.A.'s office had begun compiling their case against Sam. Ten months since she'd last had a drink, somehow managing to make herself a credible witness because of that fact, which was incredibly important. If her testimony wasn't believed, Sam could get off on the murder charge, and no one wanted that. But in order to get it over and done with, she had to be prepared. She'd been expecting the summons to the Watch House, thankfully, ready to meet with Desmond Granger once again, despite rumors of his death on Earth. Escorted to the private interview room that had been set aside for this meeting, she waited until the door was closed behind her before allowing herself to meet Desmond's gaze, a little pale but mostly in control. "Hey - uh, I mean, good afternoon, Mr Granger."

"Miss De Luca," Desmond returned the greeting, looking very dapper in a navy blue suit, dapper enough to give his movie-star brother a run for the money. "Please, have a seat," he said, gesturing toward a chair across from him. "Would you like some coffee" A donut?" Yes, even at the Rhy'Din Market Watch House, coffee and donuts were a staple and in plentiful supply. "This is very informal, so try to relax. You're not on trial here. This is just to prepare you for what to expect."

"Uh ..." Her smile was nervous but genuine as she moved away from the door, neatly taking a seat in a manner that would have surprised Michael if he'd been there. He was more used to her draping herself all over the furniture - and him - without much care for how she presented herself. "Thanks, I'm good," she nodded, refusing the offer with another awkward smile. "Have to say, you're looking good for a dead guy."

A small smile flickered across his face, albeit briefly. "The rumors of my death have been greatly exaggerated, and I'm hoping to keep them that way for at least a little while yet." Once she was seated, he took a seat across the table from her, a cup of coffee close at hand, a thick manilla folder in front of him. "I hear your sister is my brother's best friend. Small world," he remarked, hoping to put her further at ease. He wasn't there to accuse her or blame her for anything. They were allies in this, with one common goal - to put Samuel Nicoletti where he belonged.

It worked - she laughed a little, her smile fully relaxing as he pointed out that he wasn't as inhumanly cool as he first appeared. He was Jon Granger's brother, and that made him a little less of a gorgon. "Yeah, it is. I worked with Jon a little while back." Though that brief jaunt back on stage had been enough to tell her she never wanted to act again, it was a gold star in her book - she'd held down a job for the length of time she was contracted. Big points when it came to swaying a jury. "I, uh, I was told that this is a briefing" Something about already knowing what I have to say, I just need to be reminded what the process is."

It was a bit strange knowing Elena's sister probably knew his brother better than he did, but it didn't really matter. Des was building a life for himself in Rhy'Din, and part of that life was getting better acquainted with the family he had here, including his younger brother. He folded his hands on top of the folder that was situated in front of him on the desk, as she turned the conversation back to the reason for their meeting. "The process isn't what?s important. What's important is that you need to understand that the defense is going to do everything they possibly can to discredit you and break you down. Their goal is to convince the jury that you aren't a credible witness. You know what that means."

"I know." And that was what she was afraid of, among other things. The danger didn't concern her even half as much as the courtroom itself. "I know that my counsellor is giving a character statement before I go on the stand; hopefully that'll give people a better idea of what I was and what I am. The other lawyer is gonna pick holes in me, isn't he?" She bit her lip worriedly. "They're gonna say that because I was drunk then and I'm sober now, there's no way I could remember it clearly."

Though his expression remained neutral, there was a hint of very real compassion in his eyes. He might be a trial lawyer, but he was still a human being, and the reason he'd gone into criminal law was to help and protect people like her and get scumbags like Nicoletti off the streets. "I'm not gonna sugarcoat it. This is serious stuff. They are going to use every means at their disposal to discredit you. That means digging into your personal life and putting it on public display." He paused for a moment to lean back in his chair, either in quiet observation or thought for a moment. "Tell me again what happened that night." He wasn't asking to refresh his own memory, but to make sure they found any holes in her story now before they got to trial.

Not for nothing had Elena made a career out of acting until relatively recently. As soon as they settled into the meat of the conversation, she relaxed, and when he asked her to tell the story, she gave him her statement, almost word perfect, delivered in a calm voice that only wavered when she reached her own involvement in the clean up of the murder itself. It wasn't a role; she was playing Elena De Luca to the best of her ability, relying on that gentle buffer to keep herself from cracking even under this gentle pressure.

He didn't want to do it, but this was where his job became difficult. He needed to play the part of the defense and attempt to crack her, to break her down, to poke as many holes in her story as he could, so that between them they could repair the holes and prepare her for the defense. And with that in mind, he started grilling her, asking her for more details, minutia even, making sure she remembered it all in as much detail as possible. He asked her to repeat the story again and again, until she could tell him what had happened in her sleep. It was unpleasant, but necessary. He needed her to be prepared, not only for the sake of the trial, but for the sake of her own sanity and self-confidence. Her tears didn't matter. Tears were good. Tears would make her human and would gain sympathy with the jury, so long as she didn't break down completely. "I'm going to have to ask you about your personal relationship with Sam. I want you to tell the jury exactly how he treated you. Don't hold back."

Elena bore the minute grilling with an odd kind of dignity, confident that he wasn't doing anything to her that his counterpart wouldn't when she was on the stand. Even when the tears came - and they came, the memory was too distressing not to hurt - she kept talking, clear and concise, holding his gaze no matter how bullied she felt. Yet as soon as he mentioned her personal relationship with Samuel Nicoletti, Elena flinched. It was raw and visible and sharp, and there was no way in hell she was faking it. "Are you sure they'll ask about that?"

Desmond Granger

Date: 2013-08-11 08:47 EST
"Elena," he started, as gently as he could. "I know you don't want to play the victim here, but that's exactly what you are. You were forced into doing something you knew was wrong. You were afraid for your own life. You were afraid what they'd do to you if you didn't cooperate. The defense is going to try and convince the jury that you were a willing accomplice. We need to make them understand that you were as much a victim as the man who was murdered."

She held his gaze for a long moment, one hand cupping the other in her lap as she absorbed his reasoning. "You really want me to tell you everything?" she asked quietly. It was something she hadn't done at all - not for her family, and certainly not for Michael. But she understood Desmond's reasons, and she knew she was going to have to talk about it at least twice, here and in the courtroom. "Okay."

With a gentle sigh, she began to speak again, sparing no detail. She told him about the drinking, about the wooing, about Sam's unpredictable temper, about unexpected blasts of fury and the lack of reason for them; she told him about incidents when she had seen him lose his temper with nothing and beat grown men until they lost consciousness, about the numerous occasions when she had been on the receiving end of those temper tantrums. She even steeled herself to detail how violent Samuel Nicoletti could be during sex, the number of times it wasn't rape simply because she was too drunk to risk fighting back. By the time she was done, she was shaking, her nails digging into her own palms. "And you want me to say all that, to a full courtroom and a jury?"

Desmond frowned as she told him her story, his heart going out to her, though he couldn't let her know that or let anyone see what he was feeling. He had to shove those feelings aside, especially in the court room, and do his job. He'd heard everything she had to say before - he'd witnessed it as a boy whenever his father had come to visit. He'd seen it growing up on the streets of New York and heard it time and again from victims of crime. It had hardened him enough that he was relentless at his job, no sympathy for those who abused others, especially men who thought they were above the law. He hated them, plain and simple, and had devoted his life to giving them what they deserved. That compassion showed through for a moment as he reached across the table, opening his hand in invitation to hers. "You can do it, Elena. You've come this far. There's no turning back now."

It was his job to prepare her for every possibility, and this was not only a possibility but a probability. He was planning on using Nicoletti's abusive behavior to paint Elena as a victim, and if he had to stoop to grilling her about the gory little details to gain the jury's sympathy, that's exactly what he'd do. "All you have to do is be honest. That's all."

She took the comfort that was offered, gripping his hand as her throat tightened. "None of my family knows anything about all this," she told him unhappily. "None of them. I haven't even told my boyfriend. But they're gonna be in court, they're all refusing to stay away. They're gonna know about everything that I let happen, everything that I was too scared or too weak to stop. They're never gonna be able to look at me the same way again. I'm scared, Mr Granger. I'm really scared."

He gripped her hand, offering warm reassurance, at least in the privacy of the briefing room. It was something he would be unable to do in the courtroom. She would just have to trust him. "Then maybe you should tell them before they find out in a court of law," he suggested. "You have every reason to be scared, Elena, but I swear to you, you are going to feel so much better when all this is over. You're going to feel free."

"I'm not scared of him," she admitted quietly, the confidence coming back to her voice as she deliberately pushed those unhappy memories away, gently slipping her hand from his. "I'm not scared of his dad, or their thugs. I'm scared that everyone I love is going to walk away from me when they find out what I've done, what I didn't do. I can't risk that happening before the trial, sir. It's selfish, but I need them. They already pulled back from me once, I can't walk into this knowing they all hate me. I really can't."

He offered another smile, wishing he could explain to her what he already knew - that they wouldn't hate her, that they'd be hurt and angry, but not at her. That they would finally understand the truth and would only come to love her more for her bravery, but she probably wouldn't believe him. She'd just have to find out for herself. "They won't hate you," he told her, retracting his hand to settle it against the manilla folder on the table, which he had not yet opened. It wasn't his job to coddle her, but to prepare her for the worst. "I'm not gonna lie to you. It's gonna be hard, maybe one of the hardest things you've ever done, but if you don't do this, there's a good chance Nicoletti walks, and you don't want that. You have to be brave, Elena. It's almost over, and then you can put it all behind you forever."

"There's no chance I'm not doing it," she told him firmly, strong enough in herself to be able to put her foot down on this. "My mom doesn't want me to, but I know that there isn't enough strong evidence to guarantee a conviction. Sam has to go down, and once he's gone, you might be able to get his dad, too." She drew in a slow, deep breath. "I know I don't look like much, but I'm doing this, Mr Granger. Regardless of the consequences."

Desmond smiled, pleased with her answer and her conviction. "All right, then. From the top. Tell me what happened that night again." And so it would go for another two hours, breaking in the middle for lunch and to give her a well-deserved breather. By the time they were done, Elena was more than prepared for the trial and for the challenges that awaited her. The rest was up to Desmond.

((Will Elena survive the trial without breaking down" Will Desmond convince the jury to put Nicoletti behind bars for good" Will anyone else get hurt before all is said and done? Stay tuned to find out! Huge thanks to Elena's player for this scene. It was much fun! :grin: ))