Topic: No Sense, All Feeling (AU)

Jo Winchester

Date: 2012-05-24 05:03 EST
Breakfast had been a very quiet affair, though highly entertaining to Brian, who'd spent the half hour or so watching Nim and Dean steadfastly ignore one another, at least outwardly. His meal finished, he pushed up from the table. "Got a few errands to run before we open up," he informed the pair still sat down. "I'll be back in a couple of hours." He pretended not to see the slightly panicked look that Nim sent his way, nodding to Dean in a friendly manner before taking his leave.

Dean only grunted in reply as he pushed the last bit of scrambled egg around on his plate. From the look on his face, he was lost in thought again, but whether he was worried about what was going to happen when Bobby arrived or feeling bad about his little argument with Not-Jo or just feeling like a fish out of water, it was hard to say. Probably all of the above.

Nim, for her part, didn't actually speak until they heard the sound of the outer door being locked behind Brian, dark eyes fixed on her plate for a long moment. Then she seemed to steel herself, lifting her head to flicker a glance toward Dean. "How's your arm?" she asked in a rush, not wanting to hear that she'd actually hurt him, but equally not wanting the blow and what had earned it to be dismissed out of hand.

He tilted his gaze at her when she deigned to speak to him again, shrugging. "It's fine. I've had worse." Far worse, but this....Jo....didn't seem to remember him or any of his history. It was probably better that way anyway. "You dug a bullet out of that arm once." He just sort of blurted that out, unsure why he was telling her that. Maybe he just needed her to know that whatever it was she might think of him now, they had been friends once. Or more than friends. He wasn't quite sure how to define it.

Her eyes met his, clear and touched with only a little guilt for their argument. It wasn't over, in her mind, but she was still debating whether or not to continue here and now, or to wait until he had forgotten how riled she'd gotten at his over-protective teasing. Something about him pushed her buttons. She wasn't sure how she felt about that. "At least it wasn't rock-salt," she offered with a shrug of one shoulder. There was a pause. "This is a really awkward silence. I might have to go put the jukebox on."

"Sorry." He frowned, feeling as awkward as she was, but unsure how to remedy that. There had always been some sort of sexual tension between them, or so he thought, but now it just seemed awkward. "You know..." he started after a moment's contemplation. "I can't say I'm entirely unhappy to be here. I mean....You're alive, Bobby's alive. Who knows who else might still be kicking. It's just....It's....kind of a shock, you know?" He'd actually managed to string together more than two sentences in partial explanation of his feelings, which he tended to mostly keep to himself.

Honesty. The downfall of the person trying to keep herself under some kind of control. "I can understand that," she nodded carefully, trying not to revel in the thrill of his admission that he was happy that she was alive, even if she wasn't entirely who he remembered. But honesty called for honesty, and now it was her turn. "I can't say I'm not pleased you're here myself," she confessed, staring fixedly at her empty plate, as though the residue of breakfast meats and eggs could give her the courage to admit to this with some kind of dignity. "Look, I know I'm not the person you want me to be. I know I've gotta be a disappointment to you. But I know that I know you, somehow." Her eyes finally lifted to his once again. "It feels like ....like we were close, and I ....Even without knowing how close, I kinda want that back."

He arched a brow at her honesty. When had the two of them ever been honest with each other" They'd always managed to skirt around honesty or fought like cats and dogs, but beneath it all, he felt some kind of undefinable and undeniable connection. "The day you died..." He broke off, wondering if this was too much honesty. He shook the thoughts from his head, not ready to talk about that again. "You're not a disappointment. I just....I don't think I can go through that again." How many times have I lost Sam" he thought to himself. How many times do I have to keep losing the people I love"

Nim felt herself bristle, warning signs showing in the faint furrow of her brow, the way her shoulders stiffened. But surprisingly, rather than immediately snap at him, she kept her mouth shut, rising to her feet to begin gathering the plates together. "So ....what?" she asked, when she thought she might be calm enough to say something without it sounding petulant. She was almost right. "You're just going to cut yourself off from everybody, and ....and ....God, that's so selfish! You're not the only one who'd miss out. What do you want, do you want me to give you permission to become a lonely, cruddy old hermit the rest of your natural?"

He furrowed his brows at her, confused by her outburst. Women really were from Venus....or somewhere. They sure confused confused the hell out of him and always had. "I didn't say that. Don't put words in my mouth." He pushed away from the table to help her clean up from breakfast, gathering up dirty dishes and taking them to the sink.

"No, you didn't say it, but that's what you're implying," Nim objected, leaving her pile of crockery where it lay to push her hair out of her eyes as she looked up at him indignantly. "It sounds as though you've just decided that you're not going to let me know you again, or get to know me, just in case one of us dies. Which is just stupid." She rolled her eyes at him. "I thought you were supposed to be smart." Dumping her armful of plates into the sink, she turned the water on, reaching for the liquid soap.

He set his own pile of dirty dishes near the sink, turning then to lean against the counter as he watched her fill the sink with soapy water. "Well, since you already know what I'm thinking and feeling, I guess there's no point in telling you, is there, Miss Smarty Pants?" He pushed off the counter to finish clearing off the table, scowling in irritation, not really feeling like arguing.

"Oh, yeah, name calling is real mature," she snorted over her shoulder at him, rolling her eyes as she waited for the sink to fill. "How about you actually say what you're thinking and feeling, rather than just hinting and implying and leaving me to fill in the blanks, since I'm obviously so wrong about everything about you?"

He had never claimed to be mature. He was still a kid in a lot of ways. He'd never really had much of a childhood. Forced to grow up too quickly, it had left him emotionally damaged, often reverting to childlike behavior simply because he didn't know any better. "I'm not a quitter, if that's what you think." He deposited the remaining dishes and pans on the counter near the sink and snagged a towel to start drying dishes as she washed.

Jo Winchester

Date: 2012-05-24 05:09 EST
"Really?" She held his gaze for a long moment, unaware of quite how much of the stinging hurt of his apparent rejection of her offered friendship was clearly visible in the darkness of her eyes. Her jaw stiffened for a moment as she bit her lip, turning her face away to look down at the sink. "Then I guess I'm the one being selfish, huh?" She plunged her hands into the steaming water, and abruptly withdrew with a loud yelp, shaking her right hand out wildly as blood welled up from a nick on the pad of her forefinger. "Damn it!"

He held her gaze for as long as she wanted to stare him down. "Really," he replied, having no idea she'd mistaken his admission of grief at her death for rejection of her friendship. "What the hell are you talking about?" he exclaimed, as she turned away, sounding and feeling more than a little frustrated with her sudden shift of mood. He narrowed his eyes at her, but then she was yelping in pain, and whatever they were arguing about was suddenly forgotten. He reached for her hand without further thought to examine the nick on her finger. "Let me see."

It wasn't a bad cut, just a small nick from the sharp knife hidden beneath the suds, but thanks to the hot water on her skin, the blood was welling up faster than it might otherwise have done. Feeling like an idiot for hurting herself on washing up, Nim fell silent, blushing as Dean took hold of her hand. At least, she assumed the blush was because of her embarrassment. She wasn't giving herself time to think about that moment of flaring desire last night, when his finger had touched the sensitive flesh of her scars, or the way that same desire was flaring now. Looking up at him, she shrugged. "I'm such a clutz. It's not bad."

He gently dabbed at the blood on her finger with the kitchen towel, unworried that it would stain. "It's my fault. I made you angry." He moved closer so that he could staunch the blood with the towel and apply pressure to her finger to stop the bleeding. He'd seen enough of her blood to last him a lifetime. "It'll be okay. I don't think you need stitches." He kept his eyes focused on her finger, unaware of her blush or any embarrassment she might be feeling. She might not remember him, but as far as he was concerned, he'd known her for years.

"You know, you're the only person who's ever made me that angry?" she offered, the anger forgotten now in the wake of her humiliating injury. Her lips curved in a rueful smile as she looked up at him. "You haven't even been here twenty-four hours, and you're getting more out of me than anyone has in two years. You're either really annoying on purpose, or there's more between us than you're letting on." Her smile turned to a smirk as he commented on her wound, embracing her embarrassment as her skin cooled a little. "Ah, but will I survive the night?" she asked teasingly. "I might need someone to stay with me in case I have delayed shock or something."

He would have replied to her statement, but she was already moving on, and unless he was mistaken, she was openly flirting with him. "You don't remember me, but you're stealing my lines." He smiled, teasing, a little amused, but a little troubled, as well. "My bedside manner isn't the best, but I think you'll survive," he proclaimed as he pulled the towel away to peer at her finger, suddenly aware how close they were standing to each other, remembering how she'd touched his cheek last night and even kissed him goodnight. He wasn't the type to blush, but the thought made his insides twist and turn in ways he didn't want to think about.

Her smile returned, the bad mood and anger completely gone now as her naturally sunny expression lit up her face all over again. "Well, I can't let you stay on top all the time, can I?" she asked with a wicked amount of flirty innocence as he inspected her finger. The bleeding had already stopped, showing the cut to be tiny. "You might get a big head." As soon as she said it, Nim felt herself flush, just as aware of him as he was of her, sharing the burning twist with him as her gaze flickered involuntarily from his eyes to his lips and back again. She swallowed, unable to keep herself from smiling still as she responded to his proclamation with, "Who said anything about bedside?"

He shifted his gaze to quirk a brow at her, still grasping her hand. "Are you flirting with me?" he asked, curiously. It wasn't like she'd never flirted with him before, but she had always confused the hell out of him, and he'd never really been sure exactly how she'd felt about him. Even talking to her ghost hadn't really cleared things up. "You know..." He glanced at her hand, dabbing at her finger one last time, just because. "Your mother didn't like me at first, but I think I grew on her."

His question confused her a little. She'd assumed that she felt this warmth, this closeness with him because they'd been that close to one another when she had been Jo. The fact that he needed to ask if she was flirting seemed to negate that assumption. Her other hand closed over his as he dabbed at her finger. "You really need to ask me that?" she asked him searchingly, leaning unconciously closer as she spoke. "I'm a big girl, you know. I don't need anyone's permission to act on how I'm feeling."

"How are you feeling?" he countered. It seemed a logical question to ask, all things considered, and he was curious. If she was feeling any of the mutual attraction - the sparks they'd always seemed to create when they were together - then maybe part of her remembered him more than she thought. The problem he couldn't quite wrap his head around was that while she looked like Jo, she wasn't Jo. Not really, not anymore. But that part of her that was Jo was in there somewhere; he was sure of it. "Brian might have something to say about that. He loves you like a father, you know." He had been there less than a day, but he wasn't born yesterday. Any idiot could see that much.

"Brian's not stupid enough to challenge me on sex," Nim laughed suddenly, lowering her eyes very briefly before she looked back into his eyes. And it was a proper look this time, the sort of look that pierces deep and knocks you speechless, and holds you in a silence that speaks louder than words. Did he really need her to tell him how she was feeling" Wasn't it obvious" Admittedly, she hadn't actually analyzed it herself, but ....

She licked her lips nervously, her cheeks flushing in gentle response to the unrelenting coil of undeniable attraction he evoked in her. "I don't think I'm wordy enough to be able to say exactly how I'm feeling," she managed finally, her voice low in the stillness around them. "If I was cheesy about it, I guess it'd be ..." Am I really going to say this? "Love at first sight."

He locked onto that gaze, green eyes lost in brown, gazing into her eyes like he was looking deep into her soul. There was something there, like there always had been before, but whatever it was seemed strangely deeper in its intensity than it ever had before, and then she shocked him to his core by telling him she....she what? What was she trying to say' Was she in love with him'

His mouth fell open, unsure what to say or think, his heart suddenly pounding. Of all the girls he'd ever known, ever been with, as far as he could remember, not a single one had ever told him as much. Not even Lisa. She had caught him off guard and rendered him completely speechless.

Jo Winchester

Date: 2012-05-24 05:14 EST
That gaze was too intense to hold for long, burning too fiercely for the silence that enveloped them. And that silence was too long. Nim didn't have much in the way of experience to call upon; the longer the silence went on, the more she convinced herself that she'd said too much or assumed wrongly or had just destroyed any chance of any regained closeness. Her gaze lowered quickly as she drew in a quick breath, exhaling with a smile that was shy and embarrassed and trying to ease past her mistake without drawing too much attention to it. "We, uh ..." She glanced toward the sink, forcing herself not to linger on his lips when her eyes returned to his. "We should finish."

Had she been anyone else - anyone who didn't matter - he'd have kissed her, right then and there, and put an end to her misery and his, but she meant too much to him to rush things along and take advantage of her feelings just so he could get laid. Not this time, and it surprised even him. His gaze drifted from her eyes to her lips, and he once again recalled the last time - the first time - he'd kissed her, as she lay dying. Something twisted in him again, painfully, grief mingled with longing, but he turned away in hopes she wouldn't notice. "Yeah..." he agreed. "Only this time you're drying." He handed her the towel that was now stained with her blood and traded places with her at the sink.

Relieved that he hadn't taken offense, that she hadn't made him so awkward he never wanted to be anywhere near her again, Nim's smile relaxed, her eyes rolling with another of those rueful looks as he pressed the blood-stained towel into her hands and manuvered her out of his way. "Oh yeah," she drawled, leaning one hip against the counter as she watched him. "'Cos both of us getting cut is so much better than just the one." Had she just been rejected" It didn't feel like it, but then nothing had happened, either. The uncertainty wasn't helping with her confusion.

He smirked, teasing, green eyes dancing with that old Dean sense of humor, despite his uneasiness at being so close to her. "Don't worry, Mother. I'll be careful." He went to pull the watch off his wrist and frowned thoughtfully as he noticed the hands had stopped moving at a particular time. "Huh. That's weird."

"What is?" Curiosity sparked up in her gaze as she leaned closer to look at the watchface, her bare arm resting against his sleeve as she glanced up at him. "And don't call me Mother, that makes what I just said so wrong." She snickered quietly, shaking her head in amusement.

He was staring at his watch with a puzzled expression on his face. His watch had only stopped a few times before, always when he was no longer in his own world or his own time. He tapped the watchface, but it remained stuck where it was - at the exact time when he'd killed the leader of the Leviathan and had moments later, found himself in the alley in back of Morgan's Landing. "Watch stopped."

Lowering her eyes to the watchface herself, Nim found herself frowning along with him, curious and intrigued. "That's around the time Brian found you out in the alley," she commented thoughtfully. A thought occurred to her, the sort of thought that wasn't pleasant but had to be faced. "Wonder if it'd start up again if you ....left."

He gave her a sidelong glance, arching a single brow. "It's just a watch..." He had to bite his tongue before he called her Jo again. It was going to take some getting used to calling her by a completely different name. He pulled the watch from his wrist and set it on the counter. He had no emotional attachment to that particular possession. It was just a watch. He rolled up his sleeves, one at a time. "So, why'd he name you Nimue" He have a thing for Arthurian Legend?"

The change of subject worked, drawing her mind away from the depressing consideration that he probably wanted to get back to his own world/Earth/dimension/whatever as soon as possible. "He didn't call me Nimue," she laughed, shaking her head as he rolled up his sleeves. "He offered me his daughter's name. Apparently his wife chose it, and it grew on him. I dunno, it just ....it was such a great honor to be offered a name that meant so much. Why, doesn't it suit me?" Her dark eyes twinkled teasingly as she waited to be handed the first of the dishes.

He shrugged his shoulders just before plunging his arms up to the elbows in hot, soapy water. "It's just gonna take some getting used to." He pulled out the knife that had been the culprit in injuring her finger and carefully wiped it clean and rinsed it. "Better let that one dry on its own. Bad luck and all." He set the knife in the dishdrainer for later and continued washing the less dangerous dishes. "You never told me what happened to his family." He assumed demons had gotten them, but that's what he always assumed because he'd heard that story once too often.

Careful not to wipe the bloody part of the towel over anything he handed out of the sink, Nim settled into a rhythm as she dried the dishes as he washed. At least he wasn't outright rejecting her chosen name; that was something, at least. Her gaze snapped up for a moment when he asked about Brian, lowering to the plate in her hands as she answered quietly. "It's not really my place to, I guess, but ..." But I can't actually deny you anything, even if you don't ask for it.

She cleared her throat as this thought made itself known. "Marsha died giving birth," she explained quietly. "Something about the placenta rupturing and the baby dying first, then she died on the operating table while they were trying to stop the bleeding. Nothing demonic or anything like that. It's just so unfair that something like that could happen to him."

"Oh," Dean muttered, quieting, feeling a sad tug at his heart at the news. It was sad no matter how they'd died, but for some reason, it seemed even sadder to him that they'd died in such a supremely unfair way. Had it been demons, Brian could have at least sought vengence, but how did you deal with the grief that came from losing someone simply because fate had decided it should be that way' Dean realized in that moment that death was tragic, no matter how it came about.

"I've met Death. Cheated him a few times. Doubt I'll be able to cheat him again," he rambled, unsure why he was telling her this, but it just came out for some reason. The knowledge that Brian had given Jo his unborn daughter's name only served to reinforce Dean's belief that he thought of her as a daughter, which was both good and bad in Dean's point of view. Good for Jo, bad for Dean.

"You never know," she said quietly. "That's the Death you've met before. You haven't met the one here." She didn't know why, but she had the sudden feeling that he'd withdrawn again. It was strange with Dean; he could be warm and flirting and easy, and just as easily become quiet and cool, as though he was deliberately stepping away from her. "Am I just giving you excuses not to engage with ..." She trailed off, shaking her head. "You know what? That's nosy and rude, I'm not saying it." She put the last dish away, dropping the damp towel on the counter. "I should get dressed. This get up really isn't good for pretending I'm not totally fixated on you." She shrugged, offering him a wink and a smirk.

Jo Winchester

Date: 2012-05-24 05:20 EST
She wasn't too far off in her assessment of him. It wasn't that he was trying to pull away from her exactly, but every time they started to get close, he got scared. He pulled the drain in the sink, letting the water and leftover soapsuds swirl their way down the drain, snagging the towel to wipe his hands dry, unconcerned about the blood that was already dried on the towel. Her blood. He turned to face her as he dried his hands, a confused expression on his face. "There you go again. If you want something, maybe you should just come right out and say it."

Nim rubbed her forehead, half turned away as she frowned awkwardly. "Well, it's not as simple as that, Dean, and you know it," she answered, meeting his gaze with another of those only too honest looks. "I can't ask you for what I want because it's not fair. It's selfish, and you have so much to deal with right now, you really don't need me complicating things for you, so I can't say what I want." Her expression twisted, almost threatening tears for a moment before she got herself under control, hoping he wasn't seeing just how confused and yearning she was feeling. "I'm just making it worse ....which is something I excel at, believe me."

He held onto the towel longer than he had to, wringing it between his hands while he listened to her reply, noticing the emotions that were threatening just beneath the surface, the barely repressed tears. She was about to cry....over him' "Jo..." He took a step forward, sighing before correcting himself. "Sorry....Nim....If it was simple....What would you want?"

She drew in a sharp breath, holding it until she had a hold on herself and the sudden turmoil of emotion he'd stirred in her. Her hands came to rest on her hips as she shrugged, her tension keeping her shoulders higher than they should be as she bit her lip. The question was so easy to answer, a single word demanding to be spoken aloud without the need for thought. It was all about the feeling. "In a word?" She glanced away, her dark gaze flickering over the ceiling, the window, the counters, before rising to meet Dean's once again. "You."

He held his breath a moment while he awaited her reply. No pretenses between them, no flirtation, no snarky remarks or witty banter, just stark honesty. Hadn't he told her last night how he felt about her, or at least how he'd felt about who she'd been, once upon a time" When she'd died, he'd felt like he'd died with her, and though he had no choice but to go on, he'd never really been the same after that. Her death had been a defining moment in his life, and now here she was, standing there right in front of him, alive and well, and telling him she wanted him. "Are you real?" he asked, his voice full of emotion, needing to know she was real, that all this was real and not just a figment of his imagination.

Her lip trembled for a moment, frustrating her with how ridiculous she felt being so vulnerably emotional. In two years, no one - no one - had brought her to any extreme of emotion, and yet Dean had brought her to anger, tears, and something she was reluctant to classify as love, but not stupid enough to deny. This wasn't a sudden feeling, it wasn't lustful attraction alone. It felt old, established, something she had been feeling for many of the years she couldn't remember. Another shrug lifted her shoulders as she took a half-step back, fully expecting him to tell her she was being stupid, that she couldn't possibly be feeling anything like this for him, not after only a few hours. "I'm as real as you are."

He felt a wave of emotions flood him. There had been so many girls, so many women - some of their names he didn't even remember - but only a few who managed to touch his heart, no matter how he might deny it. He couldn't help but feel like Jo was the one who'd gotten away, the one who might have been his match, the only one who could have fulfilled him, the only one he truly loved. Seeing her again was still something of a shock, but what was more of a shock was realizing that even though it had been two years, his feelings hadn't changed. "You....should get dressed before Bobby gets here," he told her, dragging his eyes away from her, not rejecting her outright, but afraid he'd no sooner let her in than he'd lose her again.

The sparkle of her eyes was one he did not want to see, brought to light as wetness found her gaze. Her throat tightened as she nodded, accepting that he seemingly couldn't or wouldn't return the unthinking, uncalculated emotion that had spurred her on with such sharp honesty. "You're right, I should," she agreed, dropping her gaze from his. "Uh, there's clean clothes in that cupboard there -" her hand rose to indicate the right storage "- if you wanted to change. I'll, uh ..." Stepping backwards, she nodded again. "Yeah." It was almost a relief to turn away, to try and ignore his eyes on her back.

As hard as he tried, he could not drag his eyes away from her, unable to miss the tears in her eyes, heart sinking at the realization that they had something to do with him. He couldn't deny that he wanted her, but it was too soon and it was too much of a shock. He tried to tell himself he was doing this for her, but that wasn't completely true. The truth was he was scared to death of her, or more accurately, of the feelings her presence had reignited in him. He watched her as she stepped away from him, tempted to go to her, to give her everything she wanted, but he couldn't. Not yet.

She desperately wanted him to call her back, to touch her, to say something that would temper the crush in her chest with a little hope, surprising herself. But nothing came. Squaring her shoulders, Nim somehow managed to walk out of the kitchen with a certain amount of dignity, despite the humiliation of having all but thrown herself at his feet and been left there. She didn't pretend to understand how she was feeling, or why she was feeling as she did, but if Dean couldn't respond, then she wasn't going to push.

Her footsteps padded up the stairs and along the hall, stilling as soon as the door to her room closed. When she returned downstairs, it would be with a smile, fresh and clean, dressed and armored again to keep her unexpected emotion under wraps. But for now ....she needed the silence and privacy of her bedroom for a few minutes. He hadn't seen her cry yet; he wasn't going to see it now.

He hadn't seen her cry, but he had heard her, in the still of the night, waking screaming from nightmares. He understood those nightmares more than anyone, maybe even more than she did, and he'd wanted to go to her, to hold her close, to comfort her and keep her safe in his arms, but Brian had been there. Brian, who was like a father to her, who loved her in ways he couldn't even fathom. Dean turned away as she disappeared from the kitchen, throwing the towel on the counter with a muttered curse.

One way or another, they had to figure out what the hell was going on here before they both went mad. He reached for the watch with the time that had stopped at the moment he'd found himself in the alley, gazing at the watch face a moment, thoughts drifting to Jo, then to Bobby, then to Sam. If he was dead in this world, what was he doing here" And if he was here, did that mean Sam was here somewhere, too' And why was Jo here" Who or what had orchestrated all this and for what reason' Lots of questions, but no real answers. Dean shoved the useless watch in his jeans pocket for now to show to Bobby later, a possible clue to this little mystery.

He glanced up at the ceiling, knowing Jo or Nim - or whoever she was - was upstairs somewhere, changing out of those adorable pink jammies and into something else. The thought of it was enough to drive him mad. There was no one here, just the two of them. No one would know, no one would care, and though he wanted to - oh, he wanted to so badly - he couldn't. Instead, he grabbed his jacket and headed for the door. He wasn't planning on going anywhere. Until Bobby got here, he didn't really have anywhere to go. He just needed some air to sort out his head and a few minutes alone to try and think things through.

Besides, it was cold air or a cold shower, and he didn't think both of them semi-nude just a couple of doors away from one another would do anyone any good right now.

((Thanks to Dean!))